Thursday, October 4, 2007

Logical Path from Religious Beliefs to Evil Deeds

Interesting Newsweek article by Richard Dawkins. It's funny how many people argue that atheism promotes immoral behavior, which isn't true of course. First of all, atheism isn't really a "thing" (it's an absence of a belief in a supernatural creator) so it can't promote anything. If by this people mean that only through religion can people be moral then this is pattently false and it's insulting to insinuate that we'd all rape and murder if there were no threat of hell. I would think these people are just trying to justify their religious beliefs to make themselves feel better. Paraphrasing Christopher Hitchens, we don't need to believe foolish things nor do we need divine permission in order to behave well.
The following quotation from the Nobel prize winning physicist Steven Weinberg has become well known, but it is so devastatingly true that it is worth quoting again and again: “With or without [religion] you’d have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion.”
Of course, many evil deeds are done by individuals who happen to be atheists. But it can never be rational to say that, because of their nonbelief in religion, it would be good to be evil. This is an important point given how frequently you hear illogical statements about how evil men like Stalin or Mao were atheists; as if that's *why* they were evil -- how silly. While that may have been both evil and atheists, they may also have both had mustaches -- neither shows any causality. You need to find out the underlying reasons why they did horrible things -- power, money, fame, glory, etc. Maybe they are just evil, crazy mo-fos. If they are atheists, all we know is that it's not because they're tying to please some invisible man in the sky. We still don't know why.

What this article shows, however, is that religiously inclined leaders not only have one more reason to be evil than atheists but they have the best reason of all -- because God told them so and they'll be punished for eternity for disobeying. The irrationality inherent in all religious/supernatural beliefs makes it that much easier to make this mental jump and cling to it faithfully in spite of any evidence to the contrary. And that scares me more than anything else!

What the world needs is more rationality; otherwise we are doomed. If religious fanatics get their hands on nukes or bio-weapons we will look back at the good ol' days when they only flew planes into buildings. As someone recently put it, "right now we have armed Christians killing Muslim civilians by the thousands in the heart of the Middle East." What part of that makes you think that there aren't millions of poor, down-trodden Arabs interested in doing whatever they can to get back at us?