A family member stated last week the common misconception that since they didn't have anything to hide, they were fine with allowing the government to tap all phone lines without a warrant. Now this argument overlooks several important issues:
- The government only has rights that the people grant it -- and we didn't grant this right; they took it.
- Worse however, is the lack of individual warrants to show that they have just cause. Now, I'm willing to admit that this process is more like looking for a needle in a haystack and that warrants may not be appropriate tool for this fight. In that case, some oversight to the program as a whole is necessary to ensure that the level of privacy invasion is appropriate as compared to the level of success in finding useful information. If not, it should stop. If so, we don't need to publicize exactly how (to the benefit of those we're trying to catch) but we at least need to know that the payback is worth the cost. Without such oversight, do you think they'd ever let on that it wasn't working -- PLEASE! The government only knows how to take more power (and more money); not how to give it back!
- A corollary to #2, and most important of all, is that our government is predicated on upholding the Constitution and the need for checks and balances -- both of which are broken by this law. We always must recognize that any power that we give to those we allow to govern us MUST have oversight -- no one is trusted absolutely -- and as we know from Watergate, McCarthyism, etc.; this is with VERY good reason!
Olbermann has a succinct comment on this very topic. And our primary fear peddler, GW, was shown again to be a liar. Shockingly, according to Bush's own words he was willing to put the telecom immunity *above* the American lives supposedly at risk until he gets his domestic spying bill passed. Wow!
It's hard to say it much better than in the following quotes from “The Rights of Conscience Inalienable” -- a sermon delivered by the semi-famous but not-as-famous-as-he-should-be John Leland (1754-1841) [thanks 1gm]:
- “that law should rule over rulers, and not rulers over the law”
- “that every law made by the legislature inconsistent with the compact, modernly called a constitution, is usurprative in the legislators and not binding on the people.”
- “that legislators in their legislative capacity cannot alter the Constitution, for they are hired servants of the people to act within the limits of the Constitution.”
